The Tears of Saint Peter
National Museum of Art, Architecture and Design, Oslo
El Greco's The Tears of Saint Peter shows the apostle alone against a bare, stormy sky, his hands clasped and his eyes lifted, weeping after he denied knowing Christ three times before the crucifixion. The gospel gives the moment a single line: Peter went out and wept bitterly. El Greco built an entire type of picture from it, repeating the subject at least six times through the 1580s, of which the Oslo canvas is one[1]. There is no crowd, no setting and no narrative detail to place the scene; only the old man's face, his raised hands and the folds of a yellow-gold cloak carry the picture. This stripped-down, single-figure format belonged to a wider group of devotional images El Greco painted again and again during his Toledo years: penitent or meditating saints shown alone at a moment of private spiritual struggle rather than in a narrative scene, among them the Penitent Magdalen, Saint Jerome and Saint Francis in Meditation[2]. Most of these were El Greco's own invention, later carried on by Spanish painters of the following century[2]. The Oslo version keeps to the pattern he had already fixed: a plain or clouded ground, a half-length figure, and an expression built to be read from a distance in a private chapel or a devout household rather than a church nave.
Where it is held
Held at National Museum of Art, Architecture and Design, Oslo, Norway.
The Oslo picture is held by the National Museum of Art, Architecture and Design. Little beyond its attribution, subject and present location is recorded for this particular canvas; a related version of the same subject is documented in the Bowes Museum in County Durham, one of at least six El Greco painted of the theme[1].
A gospel moment stretched into a type
The subject comes from a single verse shared across the gospels: after Peter denies knowing Christ for the third time, a cock crows, and Peter goes out and weeps. Painters before El Greco had shown the denial itself, often with the servant girl who challenges Peter and the fire he warms himself by. El Greco cut all of that away and painted only the aftermath: an old man alone with his guilt. He returned to the composition across at least six surviving canvases painted in the 1580s, close enough in pose and format that they read as variations on one invention rather than six independent commissions[1]. That repetition suggests a picture made to be sold or given rather than painted once for a single patron, a mode of production that suited devotional pictures of modest size intended for private prayer rather than public display.
One face among many penitents
Saint Peter in Tears belongs to a group of subjects that recur through El Greco's Toledo period: single saints caught in contrition or meditation, among them the Penitent Magdalen, Saint Dominic in Prayer and Saint Francis kneeling before a skull. Most of these compositions were El Greco's own invention rather than borrowings from an existing type, and later Spanish painters, Zurbaran prominent among them, took up the format he had established[2]. The appeal of the type was doctrinal as much as artistic. Confession, contrition and private penance were emphasised by the Counter-Reformation church in a way earlier, more triumphant sixteenth-century altarpieces had not stressed, and a single weeping saint, stripped of narrative distraction, suited that emphasis better than a crowded biblical scene[3].
A face built like an icon
El Greco trained as an icon painter in Crete before he ever reached Italy or Spain, and scholars have traced a direct link between his bust-length saints and the Byzantine icon tradition he grew up in. One study compares the structure of a Saint Peter in Tears directly against a sixth-century icon of the same saint held at Saint Catherine's Monastery on Mount Sinai, arguing that El Greco carried the icon's sense of stable, frontal religious presence into an oil-painted format while giving it the outward emotion an icon does not show[4]. The bare ground behind Peter, the close framing on the head and hands, and the absence of any setting all belong more to that icon inheritance than to the Italian religious painting El Greco had studied in Venice and Rome.
Common questions
What does The Tears of Saint Peter show?
It shows the apostle Peter alone, weeping after denying Christ three times before the crucifixion. His hands are clasped and his eyes are raised, with no other figures or setting shown, just a stormy sky behind him.
Is this the only version El Greco painted of this subject?
No. El Greco painted the same subject at least six times during his years in Toledo in the 1580s, with only minor variation between versions. A related canvas is held at the Bowes Museum in County Durham.
Why did El Greco paint so many single, penitent saints?
The Counter-Reformation church placed new weight on private confession and contrition, and single-figure devotional images suited that emphasis better than crowded narrative scenes. El Greco painted many such subjects, including the Penitent Magdalen and Saint Francis in Meditation, mostly of his own invention.
Where is The Tears of Saint Peter now?
This version is held by the National Museum of Art, Architecture and Design in Oslo.
Sources
Editorial draws on the following references, verified against the museum and public-domain image record for this work.
- [1] book Livia Stoenescu, The Pictorial Art of El Greco: Transmaterialities, Temporalities, and Media Used for: this artwork.
- [2] book Nina A. Mallory, El Greco to Murillo Used for: this artwork.
- [3] book Susie Hodge, Art: Everything You Need to Know About the Greatest Artists and Their Work Used for: this artwork.
- [4] book Andrew R. Casper, Art and the Religious Image in El Greco’s Italy Used for: this artwork.
Editorial overseen by Solis Prints. Sources verified 2026-09-03. Click a source for details, or hover over [N] in the page above to preview.
Editorial standardsMethodologyCorrectionsAI disclosureAbout the editorial team
Take it home.
More prints by El Greco →