Moeyaert belonged to a group of painters known as the Pre-Rembrandtists. These artists preferred narrative subjects from the Bible and mythology. In works like The Annunciation to the Shepherds, he used strong light and shadow to guide the viewer. His figures often have expressive gestures that tell a story. He combined Dutch realism with Italianate lighting techniques.

Modern collectors value Moeyaert for his ability to create a cinematic atmosphere. His compositions use dark backgrounds to make the central figures stand out. These prints provide a sense of drama that fits well in contemporary interiors. His work is a clear link to the artistic transition of the Dutch Golden Age.